How to Make Yogurt (Shhh… it’s REALLY easy!)

I have tried making yogurt for over a year.  It wasn’t until last week that I was successful at it, and it was ridiculously easy.  So easy, in fact, I’m not sure how I had messed it up in the first place.

I had stopped trying because I was sick of getting failed batches and wasting precious resources.  But last week, my friend Mackenzie posted yogurt-making instructions on her fabulous blog, so I decided to give it another try.  I’m so glad I did!

Here’s what you need:

Pre-made, plain (preferably organic, and if it’s greek, even better!) yogurt

Whole milk (I use raw, which provides superior results!)

Crock Pot

Plastic or wooden spoon (not metal)

Ice Chest


Plastic Colander


First, fill the crock pot with milk.  I like to fill it completely to make a good-sized batch all at once, but you can start with a quart or half-gallon.

Turn your crock pot on low and leave for three hours.

After three hours, turn off the crock pot altogether, stir your milk, and let sit an additional two hours.

At the conclusion of two hours, add some of your yogurt.  I say “some” because I’m not much of a measurer 🙂  For about half a gallon, I would do about 1/4 cup yogurt, so base your measurements off of that, give or take.  Stir it in well.

Now, wrap the crock pot in towels and place in the ice chest.  Leave it all to sit in a warm place (I leave mine in the garage because it holds all the heat from the day).  It needs to sit for 8-12 hours.  I leave mine over night.  By morning, you will have a whole crock pot full of yogurt!

BUT- you aren’t done yet.  Now, you will need to strain your yogurt because it tends to still be pretty runny.

Set your plastic colander up over a large bowl, then line it with cheesecloth.

If you don’t have cheesecloth, you can use coffee filters, although it doesn’t work as well! 

Pour your yogurt on top of the cheesecloth, then leave it to sit.  I usually leave it for an hour or so, and sometimes I have to do it in a couple batches if I make a really large batch of yogurt.  You will see the whey begin to drain off of the yogurt.  The yogurt that stays behind in the cheesecloth is a nice, thick, tangy yogurt that you can eat straight, top with raw honey, put in smoothies…. the possibilities are endless!


BUT wait!  Don’t toss the whey!  It’s wonderful stuff!  It can be used to lacto-ferment a number of things.   Save it, and tomorrow I will give you an awesome recipe for a summer favorite, lacto-fermented!




5 thoughts on “How to Make Yogurt (Shhh… it’s REALLY easy!)

  1. I am going to try this asap….I have tried in the oven and stove top several different times and failed can’t wait 🙂

  2. Pingback: Lacto-Fermented Strawberry Lemonade Recipe « naturalmommainprogress

  3. Pingback: Soaked Buttermilk Peanut Butter Brownies « naturalmommainprogress

  4. Pingback: To Your Health Tuesday: Keeping Your Colon Clean « naturalmommainprogress

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s